Welcome to the Blue Marsh Family!

Here's some helpful info about us and your coverage.

First, THANK YOU for choosing our team here at Blue Marsh. We want to make sure that you have an amazing experience working with us, so please take a few minutes to familiarize yourself with our agency.

It's a good idea to bookmark this page so you can reference it later if you need it!

Here's what we'll cover:
  • Your protection team
  • How to file a claim
  • Billing resources
  • How YOU can win prizes
  • And more!

If there's ever anything you need, you can contact us or submit a request via our online Customer Service Center.

Meet Our Team

Blue Marsh team

Front: Katie Sheaffer, Becky Fry, Mickie Shimp, Mercedes Roth, Laurie Williams, Angelina Frazzini, Jen Mento, Allison McCleary, Erika Buck
Back:  Jeremy Spiecker, Blaise Perrone, Ken Brownlow, Tom Davenport, Drew Hoffman, Mike Wagner, Steve Schappell

We're here for you.

Our protection team is personable, helpful, responsible, highly-skilled and knowledgeable.   Everything we do is focused on creating a better insurance experience. You are OUR priority. You'll see that we'll continue to work with you on a personal level and will always be waiting to help you make the best insurance decisions.

Get to know our team members here!

What to do in the event of a claim.

You really find out how good your insurance policy AND agency are when you have a claim. A claim is never fun or convenient, but we promise to make it as smooth and hassle-free as possible.

If you have a possible claim:

During Business Hours: Contact our office first. We can offer valuable advice and help you get the loss reported to your carrier. We'll be able to advise you on what to expect.

After Business Hours: Go to the claims section of our website or mobile app. There you'll find links to start a claim online or call your carrier directly. 

It's pretty rare that you'll have to file a claim, but if you do, we're here to help. If you ever have any questions about your claim, reach out to us. That's what we're here for. 

Pay your way.

We want to make paying your insurance bill easy for you. Here are some tips to avoid cancellation and make the process easy. 

We recommend choosing one of two payment methods:

1. Annual: Paying all at once will help you avoid installment fees and take advantage of annual payment discounts.

2. Monthly Bank Draft: Monthly EFT plans allow you to spread out your payments and make sure that you won't forget to mail a check to your carrier.

Each insurance carrier has their own plans, but nearly all of them offer Annual and Monthly EFT plans. Some will even combine the billing for multiple policies into one account bill. We've put all of our carrier billing portals on our website here. 

You can read about our Privacy and Billing Practices here.

Customer Service Center

Our Customer Service Center is open 24/7 to allow you to make insurance requests, pay your bill, or file a claim whenever it's convenient for you! It's a good idea to bookmark this page so you always have it ready to go!

Download Our App!
Make your life easier.

Our Blue Marsh Insurance mobile app is designed to make your life easier. You can access your billing information, report claims, request documents and even create a home inventory for yourself right on your phone. Check out more of what it can do (and download it for FREE) here.

Refer and WIN
Prizes for you + Support for our community

Have you heard of our Referral Rewards program? For every person that you refer to Blue Marsh, we send you a gift card for lunch. PLUS, you are entered into our monthly gift card drawings. PLUS we donate $10 to our Charity of the Month! And this happens EVERY TIME to refer someone to our agency. Multiple referrals = multiple changes for you to WIN! 

Last year we raised over $3,500 for local, deserving charities. Check out all of our "BIG check" photos here.

Did we earn 5 stars?
Give us a Google Review!

If you've had a good experience with our team so far, we'd LOVE your Google review. 

As a small business, Google reviews are vital in helping us spread the word about our services. 

If for some reason we missed the mark and did not earn your review, please email us and let us know what went wrong. We want to fix it.

What else can we do for you?

We handle MANY different kinds of insurance. Often times, bundling them all together with us can save you significant money. More importantly, coordinating all of your policies with our agency allows our team of insurance experts to review your coverage to make sure there are no gaps. Plus, it just makes your life easier!

Here are just a few of the types of insurance policies that we write:

  • Personal Insurance
    • Auto
    • Home
    • Renters
    • Condo
    • Umbrella
    • Motorcycle
    • RV
    • ATV
  • Business Insurance
    • Business Owners Package (BOP)
    • Commercial Auto
    • Workers Compensation
    • Business Umbrella
    • General Liability
    • Contractors
    • Restaurants
    • Breweries
    • Group Benefits
  • Life Insurance
    • Term
    • Whole Life
    • Universal
  • Health Insurance
    • Dental
    • Vision

We do all of these and more! See something you need? Email us at: MyAgent@BlueMarsh.com

Let's Get Social
Follow us on social media. 

We think you'll like connecting with us on social media! We get nerdy about insurance information every once and a while, but mostly we like to share the FUN STUFF. Follow us for news from our office, community events, and even contests - just for our social media followers.

We're so excited to have you with us!

Call Email Claims Payments