File Insurance Claim

Filing a claim:

If you want to make a claim directly with your insurance company, you can access the below list of our partner companies. If you’d like us to handle the claims for you, we’d be happy to help. If it’s during business hours, call or email us and we’ll respond immediately. If after hours, and it’s an emergency, please call your insurance company directly and also leave us a message. We’ll get back in touch with you the next business morning.

Note: These links will take you to a website outside of the Blue Marsh Insurance website. The new site may offer a different privacy policy and level of security. Blue Marsh Insurance is not responsible for and does not endorse or guarantee the new site’s content.


Donegal Group

File A Claim
(800) 877-0600


Erie Insurance

File A Claim
(800) 367-3743


FirstComp

File A Claim
(888) 500-3344


Foremost Insurance Group

File A Claim
(888) 888-0080


Grange Insurance

File A Claim
(800) 445-3030


Main Street America

File A Claim
(877) 425-2467


American Strategic (ASI)

File A Claim
(866) 274-5677


MetLife

File A Claim
(800) 638-5433


Pennsylvania Lumberman’s Insurance

File A Claim
(800) 752-1895


Philadelphia Insurance

File A Claim
(800) 765-9749


Progressive

File A Claim
(855) 758-0943


Prudential

File A Claim
(800) 778-2255


The Hartford

File A Claim
(877) 896-9320


Travelers

File A Claim
(800) 238-6225

For information on life, health and disability claims, call (877) 627-7480.

Request Your Proposal Here

Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at Blue Marsh Insurance is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!

Call Email Claims Payments
Skip to content